Wake Up and Smell the Starbucks
eRadio Magazine, September, 1999
By John Silliman Dodge
We're in the trend-spotting business. Ratings, perceptions,
musical fashion, media buzz. We get handsomely rewarded for seeing
the Next Big Things and positioning our companies to take early advantage.
Of course, some trends are easier to spot than others. This one for
- Yahoo buys Broadcast.com
- Yahoo does programming deal with Spinner for Yahoo Radio
- AOL buys Spinner (which sounds alarm bell inside Microsoft)
- Lycos debuts Lycos Radio
- Viacom releases MTV, VH1 and Nick Radio (any minute)
- AMFM putting their entire chain on the We
- Internet advertising projected to top Radio spending by 2004
- Online listenership doubling every six months and likely to start tripling
- One listener in five doesn't like his station's mix and is ripe for pick-off
1999 will go down as the year that music, Radio and the Web came together
to create the Big Bang. To our industry's credit, most Radio managers
understand that the Internet is not an Extinction-level event. The
Web won't do to Radio what CD's did to vinyl. But let's take a moment
to realize just how large the upside of this phenomenon is. We're
clearly at the beginning of a pivotal new chapter in our industry.
The merger of Radio and the Web provides a valuable two-way communication
link with our audience. Finally, Radio can play the direct, accountable
matchmaker between our audience and our advertisers. Now we can move
beyond irregular, anecdotal, biased input and have real-time, daily
dialog. We can document listener feedback. We can use it to create
Now it's gonna get good.
Let's say you run the dominant CHR in a top ten market.
Or you've been charged with leading your group's Internet marketing
efforts. Your site is live, or at least in the planning stages. You're
looking for the best possible competitive edge. What do you do to
take your Web to the next level? Not just stream your air signal.
You're probably already doing that. In fact, if you're not streaming
today, you're not going to be competitive tomorrow. It's time to consider
Webcasting-complimentary, Web-based music channels on your site that
stream alongside the broadcast channel and serve niches that your
air signal can't target. Here' how it might work:
Rather than spread your mainstream CHR music mix over
too broad an age/sex range, consider two additional Web channels.
Channel One becomes the Alternative/CHR mix that skews younger and
more male. Channel Two becomes the Adult-leaning CHR that keeps your
30+ listeners from being picked off by a new young AC. It's a self-directed
preemptive strike; you "attack" yourself before a competitor can.
The benefits are obvious: your flanks get protection, the brand stays
in tact, marketing and database-building opportunities increase, more
targeted ads run in more space, and you offer more incentives for
listeners to stay in the family.
Observe Toyota's cluster tactics. They make sure that
nobody has to leave their brand by programming the Camry straight
down the middle of the road. The Tercel and Corolla appeal to the
younger demos and Avalon and Lexis to the upscale audience. Five formats,
one channel. Everyone's needs get met.
And meeting listener's needs has never been more important.
Industries that have never been on our side of the dial are jumping
into this space at a dizzying rate. Who can blame them? There's no
FCC to deal with, the technology is freely available and anyone with
operating capital can launch his own channel.
Let's take a look at the new competition:
- Integrated Commerce Sites (such as NetRadio)
- Integrated Music Sites (MTV, SonicNet, RollingStone Radio)
- Pure Music Webcasters (Spinner)
- Portal Sites planning or now offering Radio (Lycos, Yahoo, AOL)
- Aggregators & Retransmitters (broadcast.com, WebRadio)
- Retailers (Amazon, CDNow, Barnes and Noble, Wherehouse, Borders)
- Record Labels (BMG, Universal, Sony, WEA, EMI)
- Smaller scale Webcasters (Eclectic Radio, Radio Gaga, HardRadio, Shoutcasters)
- Terrestrial broadcasters repurposing their stream and/or webcasting complimentary formats from their site
- Pure Web-based brand extensions by the major broadcast groups.
- Organizations and individual "My Web Radio Site"; scenarios.
Some of these marketing budgets are bigger than yours.
Some of this brand power is going to sting you. It's time to do some
scenario planning, some SWOT analysis (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities,
threats). Time to recognize what Radio has that pure Web plays don't
I chatted with Steve Dinardo,
VP/GM of CBS-owned KLLC-FM, San Francisco better known as Alice@97.3.
"If you look at why Radio is vibrant and healthy, it's about more
than just the records. Relationships have always been Radio's strong
suit. People look to stations to bring them services, to help them
make choices. Radio has created a bond, a trust with the consumer
in a way the Web can't. Having already established the relationship
gives us a huge advantage. So for us the Internet becomes another
stick, another channel to further our relationship with the consumer.
And if through the Web, Radio can help listeners quickly learn more
about goods and services from our advertisers, then everybody wins."
Alice isn't streaming yet but they do publish their
playlist on the Web, the result of a partnership with San Jose-based
GetMedia. Go to www.radioalice.com
(I site which I helped design, by the way) and you can view the last
ten artists and song titles. Scrolling across this list brings up
the CD cover art, the ability to hear more song samples from each
CD and the option to purchase. GetMedia is responsible for fulfillment
while Alice takes a percentage of each sale.
Alice partnered with another Web services concern, Xoom.com
to create a listener's club called "Alice's Click." When listeners
join, Alice logs their E-mail addresses and preferences. In exchange
they get free email, chat, and free Web hosting for their personal
sites through the Zoom domain. And Alice gets the opportunity to market
back to core listeners. The site gets updated daily with morning show
news, new promotions, new editorial and the real time playlist. They're
looking for more content such as movie and restaurant reviews to support
listeners' lifestyles and provide even more reasons to use the Alice
Web as a daily resource.
Dinardo's aim is to capture the E-mail addresses from
all points of audience contact, creating a massive listener database
that tracks preferences and histories. "Sending the right message
of interest to the right person at the right time. That's the goal."
What's next? "We want to start programming our Web with as much care
as we program the station." After streaming, Alice wants to Webcast
separate channels for new music, 80's Alice and the Greatest Bits
of the Alice morning show. Dinardo envisions a branded music portal
that covers the entire spectrum, 360 degrees of Alice. Clearly they're
doing something right with their relationships. In the hot San Francisco
Radio market, Alice is even hotter-up 38.4 percent year to date.
The new listener: young, urban, wired.
Increasing numbers of us work in downtown canyons wired to high-speed
T-1 lines. From 9 to 5 (or 7 to 7), today's knowledge worker is often
better reached via computer than Radio. Think about it-if you had
a choice between a passive box that pushed audio at you and a cool
audio/visual alternative that gave you music plus interactivity and
information on demand, which would you choose?
Imagine this new listener tuned to your Adult Alternative
Webcast and working on a budget spreadsheet at the same time. The
music is in the background, the project is in the foreground. But
the moment a song, an ad, a promotion, a message of interest comes
along she can instantly get all the information she needs to buy the
record, visit the advertiser's Web site, get directions to your event,
or provide her valuable opinion. This is action-ability at the maximum
point of interest. This is instant gratification.
The other important audience.
Let's talk about Advertisers. Web Radio successfully counters every
traditional objection in spades. Now Radio has tangibility. You can
hold Radio in your hands. You can see the pictures. You can download
the details. Advertisers can finally perceive Radio as a shopping
tool and not just a frequency play. You've got your ad in printable
form. You've got product information, pictures, text, audio, even
animation. And best of all, you've got a big fat broadcast pipe to
promote it with.
Adam Klein is Greater Media's
Marketing Director for two Greater Boston Radio Group stations, WBOS
and a new FM Talk that they're flipping from Smooth Jazz. "Every radio
station in Boston is sold out right now due to Web-related advertising.
You can't go a stopset without hearing "dot com." So where do
you get more inventory? "The Web. The original thinking was that we
would make money. We're not quite there yet, but we're certainly learning
how to use the Web as a marketing tool. We use our site as important
added value on a regular basis. Promotionally, it lets us remain cleaner
and more clutter free on the air. We shift a lot of advertiser detail
onto the Web where it belongs."
Klein sited a familiar set of Web benefits including
brand extension, imaging, an informational resource for listeners,
a new channel for the radio signal. I asked him about Webcasting.
"We're in the process of flipping one of our stations to FM Talk.
Wouldn't it be great if we kept Smooth Jazz on the Net?" Not only
great, but also smart. What about the challenges? "Frankly, today
we don't have the staff that knows a lot about the Web. I think it's
indicative of most of the industry. We're Radio professionals, not
sophisticated technology people. Streaming audio is new for us.
Fortunately there are a lot of companies coming that can help stations
into this space." All five of the group's Boston stations have a Web
presence courtesy of RDG and MJI Broadcasting.
If this is such a great idea, why
isn't everyone doing it? With terrestrial broadcasting, once
your tower is operational there is zero incremental cost to add audience.
Today Webcasting isn't so painless. Mark Cuban of broadcast.com (now
part of the Yahoo family) might tell you that making money today is
impossible. Just a few of the costs you have to factor: bandwidth,
performance rights fees, RIAA fees, encoding, stream software and
network OS for server, the hardware support per stream/servers, the
network hardware to support servers, footprint (space for the gear),
end-user support, hosting and site maintenance, staff, advertising...
This isn't a very encouraging picture if every line
item in your budget has to be totally above water. But consider why
the major media companies are spending huge sums acquiring and building
properties. They're not stupid. They're investing today because they
understand that to watch and wait until somebody else proves profitability
means they'll be late to the party. And in the mindshare battle that's
unfolding online, once you're late you may be too late.
So you have some "visioneering" to do to convince the
GM that this is the most significant R&D dollar he/she's ever
dedicated. If you are the GM, you know it's time to give the Web the
same quality of strategic thinking that you give your broadcast channel.
The industry has been riding the crest of a good economic wave. When
the wave hits the beach you want to be positioned to catch the next
one by having a distinct, competitive advantage. Somehow this time
I don't think it's going to be"ten in a row, commercial-free." It's
time to design, develop, bulletproof and execute your Web strategy.
Crawl. Walk. Run. The crawl
stage is about awareness. Accept the fact that the Web is a
landscape-altering new channel for Radio. It's getting cheaper and
easier every quarter. Computer processor speed is up, storage and
bandwidth costs are down, and both RealNetworks and Microsoft have
audio software plugins (codecs) that sound pretty good. Admit that
if Webcasting isn't in your plans, it needs to be. Realize that between
the national media brands, the genre-specific channels and the personalized
programming options that will soon be available to your listeners,
if you don't protect your brand, your flanks and your valuable relationships,
your future could be in jeopardy.
Walking means getting your
site up, building your listener database and streaming your audio.
There are good companies and consultants in this space to help you
with design, storage, bandwidth, e-commerce, marketing, consultation,
music, etc. There's no reason to think you have to become an overnight
expert in all things Web. The reason is speed. Quickness to market
has never been more important.
Running means Webcasting.
Streaming multiple flavors of your format from your site. It means
differentiating your office dayparts in a fundamentally new way. Flanking
yourself before a competitor does. Creating a branded music, information
and lifestyle Web portal that satisfies more of your listeners' needs.
And frankly, it means thinking like an investor and being able to
sell the long-term benefits of this currently expensive strategy to
your forward-thinking associates and superiors. Remember, if it were
cheap and easy...
Web Checklist. Once you';re
up and running, here are six important things to remember about the
- Left-Right. The Web is
left-brain. It thrives on detailed information, analysis, and logic
process. People use the Internet. (That's
why the techs call us "users.") So make the Web your utility channel.
Put all your details there. But Radio is right brain driven-its domain
is emotion, imagination, sensation and bonding. It's your entertainment
channel. It's where your relationships are nurtured. Combine left
and right, your Radio and your Web, and you create a synergy
machine with personality, content, accountability and two-way
data gathering all under one roof.
- Keep it fresh. Would you play the same
set of songs in the same order over and over for a month? Or let your
morning show tape their bits and repeat them ad infinitum? Some of the
same people who think these are stupid questions will leave their Web
untouched for weeks and not give it a second thought. This is publishing
and publishing demands new information. Next time you're tempted to
serve up day-old bread on your site, consider this statistic: Over two-thirds
of the respondents in a recent ARB study said they know you have a Web
site. Fewer than 9% visited you last month. This says, rather loudly,
"You've got nothing for me!" Make your site useful, make it valuable,
make it part of your identity, make it an up-to-the-minute resource
that your listeners rely and depend upon.
- Perfection not required. You don't have
to stream CD-quality audio. Your FM doesn't. Listeners know this is
frontier territory and they'll trade less than perfection for the increased
benefits your Web provides: music information, concert and community
news, more information and the ability to act on your advertisers'messages,
e-commerce capability and the chance to get their opinions into your
- All about Me. The direction of the Web
is toward personalization. And it's forcing mass media to adjust. With
my input and permission, Web-based software agents are tailor-making
my News, my Books, my Portfolio, my Music, my Consumer Profile. Ask
your service providers about ways that your listeners can personalize
your site to their tastes.
- Test-market new music using samples. Invite
your leading-edge listeners into regular Online Music Conferences with
your MD and let them help you shape the sound and influence the direction
of the station. They'll reward you with loyalty and great word of mouth.
Don't trust your listeners to make the right musical decisions? Buh-bye
listeners. Steve Dinardo from Radio Alice again: "We're not getting
actionable music research yet from the Web, but we're thinking seriously
about it. The Web is the perfect way for us to capture perceptions about
new artists and music that we couldn't afford to capture with our valuable
airtime. And i's perfect for our P1s, our most important customers,
the people who already love us."
- Give the people what they want. This final
tip reads like obvious advice but the features that the average site
provides, listeners actually want the least. The recent Arbitron Internet
Listening Study revealed the top ten things listeners want from a Radio
- Information about community events
- Concert information
- Titles and artist information
- Listen to your station
- See advertisers' products
- Enter contests
- See your programming schedule
- Download coupons
- Vote on music
- Buy goods and services
I don't see pictures of our DJ's anywhere on this list.
(Personalities come in at #12.) The needs on this list are about information,
input, and commerce. The message: Go long on utility, short on twirling
The Million Channel Universe won't materialize overnight.
But the Web has the power to splinter Radio as cable has splintered the
TV networks. And Webcasting is clearly the right response, the way to
turn your station's site into a branded, full service, multi-channel music
and lifestyle portal. Sure, it's expensive right now. But so were hard
drives last year. The trends show that today's bleeding edge technology
features have a way of becoming tomorrow's competitive advantages. And
anybody that can provide innovations and competitive advantages will find
a receptive ear with listeners and advertisers alike.
Everywhere we're seeing the integration of multiple media
driven by Web technology, accountability and data gathering. So learn
to understand the medium or bring in someone to help you understand. Webcasting
will reinvent Radio and invigorate both the midday and evening dayparts.
It will radically alter the ways we do focus groups, perceptuals, call-out
and auditorium testing because it's better, cheaper and faster to use
the Web. It';ll change the advertising landscape completely. And for the
listeners, once they experience more choices, more service, more input
and more interaction, there's no going back.
Radio has always found ways to survive and thrive when challenged
by new media. This time is no different. We'll adapt, modify and improve
because we're resilient. And smart. Personally, I'm looking forward to
World Wide Web Radio. In fact, I'm buying an extra pair of sunglasses.
I think we're gonna need 'em.